Through nanotechnology towards the next generation dental restorative materials
NANODENT
PN-III-P4-PCE-2021-0292
(92PCE/2022)
The solution developed in the research project will lead to a completion of the teeth treatment through the possibility of having antibacterial properties and slow release after the cavity is closed, with enhanced mechanical properties.
Project goal
The main goal of the project is to propose a potential dental restorative material with simultaneous antibacterial properties and enhanced mechanical strength, based on substituted apatitic nanomaterials (decorated with metallic nanoparticles) and natural compounds, applicable in cement base (glass-ionomer cements).
Contracting authority: Executive Unit for Financing Higher Education, Research, Development and Innovation (UEFISCDI)
Implementation period: 09/05/2022-31/12/2024
Budget: 1.200.000 lei
Project director: Dr. Habil. Radu Claudiu Fierăscu
The scientific concept of the project is based on some specific logical steps:
S1. Synthesis of modified apatitic nanomaterials (MAN), substituted with different metals such as zinc, silver, titanium etc., and further decorated with mono or bimetallic phytosynthesized nanoparticles and metallic oxides nanoparticles (such as silver and silver oxide nanoparticles, zinc and zinc oxides nanoparticles, silver/zinc bimetallic nanoparticles, etc.), with controlled morphologies and properties;
S2. Demonstration of their enhanced properties;
S3. Enriching the MAN with natural compounds (commercially available polyphenols, such as eugenol, gallic acid, or catechin, for example) – NNC;
S4. Obtaining nanoparticle-based platforms (incorporation of apatitic materials enhanced with natural compounds in glass-ionomer cements – NGI);
S5. Demonstration of the enhanced properties of the obtained
nanoparticle-based platforms (NGI);
S6. Demonstration of their efficiency in the laboratory model (simulated conditions);
S7. Validation of the proposed solution.
The main goal of the project is to propose a potential dental restorative material with simultaneous antibacterial properties and enhanced mechanical strength, based on substituted apatitic nanomaterials (decorated with metallic nanoparticles) and natural compounds, applicable in cement base (glass-ionomer cements). The degree of novelty of the proposed project emerges from the properties of the proposed material related with potential final application: simultaneous antibacterial and enhanced mechanical strength of the developed nanomaterials-based structures, applicable in the cement base (glass-ionomer cements).
The specific objectives that will ensure the achievement of project aim are:
SO1. development of substituted apatitic materials with enhanced antimicrobial properties;
SO2. phytosynthesis of mono and bimetallic nanoparticles based on “green chemistry” approaches (with extracts obtained from autochthonous plants belonging to the Lamiaceae family – Thymus serpyllum L., 1753, Satureja hortensis L., 1753, Melissa officinalis L., Mentha spicata L., etc.) and their application for the decoration of the apatitic materials, in order to obtain modified apatitic nanomaterials (MAN) with enhanced antimicrobial properties
SO3. enrichment of the MAN with natural compounds (NNC)
SO4.incorporation of NNC in glass-ionomer cements and the demonstration of their efficiency
Development of apatitic nanostructures with potential use in improving current dental restorative materials.
Deployment period: 09/05/2022 – 31/12/2022
Activities:
Optimizing the decoration of apatitic materials. Enrichment of apatitic materials modified with natural compounds – part I.
Deployment period: 01/01/2023 – 31/12/2023
Activities:
Enrichment of apatitic materials modified with natural compounds – part II. Incorporation of modified apatitic materials enhanced with natural compounds in glass ionomer cements (for obtaining platforms based on nanomaterials – NGI) and study of their influence on the mechanical properties of GIC. Demonstration and validation of the improved properties of the obtained NGIs.
Deployment period: 01/01/2024 – 31/12/2024
Activities:
Institutional & personal awards
Summary
Acidic attack by cariogenic bacteria associated with plaque biofilm development is responsible for dental caries, a biofilm-dependent infectious disease that damages teeth through mineral loss and has a high incidence of the use of polymers for clinical restoration. The complexity of oral biofilms contributes to the difficulty of developing new effective dental materials. The oral cavity is an ideal environment for microbial cell growth, persistence and plaque formation.
The presence of different microniches leads to the appearance of different biofilm communities, formed on the surface of the teeth, above the gingival crevice or at the subgingival level, on the tongue, mucous membranes or on dental prosthetic materials. In this context, nanotechnology has the potential to be explored in the development of bioactive dental materials to reduce or modulate the activities of caries-related bacteria. The main goal of the project is to propose a potential dental restorative material with antibacterial properties simultaneously with increased mechanical resistance, based on substituted apatitic nanomaterials (decorated with metal nanoparticles) and natural compounds, applicable in glass ionomer cements. The project proposal responds to a real practical demand arising from discussions with the dental community.
The degree of novelty of the proposed project emerges from the properties of the proposed material related to the potential final application: improved mechanical resistance and simultaneous antibacterial activity of the structures developed based on nanomaterials, applicable in glass ionomer cements.
The activities planned to be carried out during the first year of implementation were:
The proposed activities were carried out in full, supporting the continuation of the project in the year 2023. Thus, they identified the possibilities of incorporating different types of target materials (apatitic materials, nanoparticles, etc.) and both apatitic materials and phytosynthesized metal nanoparticles were developed and studied .
The obtained results were disseminated within the scientific community, the results of the dissemination being widely presented on the project website (Romanian version – https://icechim.ro/project/nanodent/, English version – https:// icechim.ro/project/nanodent_en/), but also through the weekly Newsletter of the Ministry of Research, Innovation and Digitalization.
No | Estimated results | Obtained results |
---|---|---|
1 | Preliminary report on the development of modified apatite nanomaterials (NAM); | The preliminary report on the possibilities to develop modified apatite nanomaterials was performed, synthesizing and characterizing a series of modified apatite materials |
2 | Report on the possibilities of incorporating the developed nanomaterials into glass ionomer cements | The report on the modification of glass ionomer cements with nanomaterials was elaborated (published as a review paper) |
3 | Preliminary report on the antimicrobial properties of apatite nanomaterials | The preliminary report on the antimicrobial properties of the obtained apatite materials was elaborated |
4 | Report on the antimicrobial properties of phytosynthesized NP | The report on the antimicrobials properties of phytosynthesized NPs was elaborated (published as two ISI articles) |
5 | Submission for publication of at least two ISI articles in Q1/Q2 journals | Three ISI articles were published in Q1/Q2 journals |
6 | Participation in at least one scientific event | Two participations in international scientific events were recorded |
7 | Participation in at least 1 invention salon | Three participations in invention salons were recorded, obtaining a series of prizes, presented on the project website |
8 | Project web page and online campaign on social media | The project website was developed, both in Romanian and in English; of the project was disseminated through social media, but also through MCID’s weekly Newsletter |
Summary
Acidic attack by cariogenic bacteria associated with plaque biofilm development is responsible for dental caries, a biofilm-dependent infectious disease that damages teeth through mineral loss and has a high incidence of the use of polymers for clinical restoration. The complexity of oral biofilms contributes to the difficulty of developing new effective dental materials. The oral cavity is an ideal environment for microbial cell growth, persistence and plaque formation. The presence of different microniches leads to the appearance of different biofilm communities, formed on the surface of the teeth, above the gingival crevice or at the subgingival level, on the tongue, mucous membranes or on dental prosthetic materials.
In this context, nanotechnology has the potential to be explored in the development of bioactive dental materials to reduce or modulate the activities of caries-related bacteria. The main goal of the project is to propose a potential dental restoration material with antibacterial properties simultaneously with increased mechanical resistance, based on substituted apatitic nanomaterials (decorated with metal nanoparticles) and natural compounds, applicable in glass ionomer cements. The degree of novelty of the proposed project emerges from the properties of the proposed material related to the potential final application: improved mechanical resistance and simultaneous antibacterial activity of the structures developed based on nanomaterials, applicable in glass ionomer cements.
The activities planned to be carried out during the second stage of the project were:
The proposed activities were carried out in full, supporting the continuation of the project in the year 2024. Thus, the activities related to the synthesis and optimization of the synthesis of apatitic nanomaterials, as well as phytosynthesized nanoparticles were continued, the modified apatitic materials enriched with natural compounds were obtained and tested from an antimicrobial point of view natural, thus offering real possibilities to put the developed solutions into practice.
The obtained results were disseminated within the scientific community, the results of the dissemination being widely presented on the project website (Romanian version – https://icechim.ro/project/nanodent/, English version – https:// icechim.ro/project/nanodent_en/).
No | Estimated results | Obtained results |
---|---|---|
1 | Final report on the development of modified apatite nanomaterials (MAN) | The final report on the development of modified apatitic nanomaterials was elaborated |
2 | Final Report on Antimicrobial Properties of Apatitic Nanomaterials | The final report on the antimicrobial properties of apatitic nanomaterials was elaborated |
3 | Final report on the antimicrobial properties of NP | The final report on the antimicrobial properties of the NPs was developed |
4 | MAN optimization report | The MAN optimization report was developed |
5 | Preliminary report on the development of modified apatitic nanomaterials enriched with natural compounds | The preliminary report on the development of modified apatitic nanomaterials enriched with natural compounds was elaborated |
6 | Submission for publication of at least three ISI articles in Q1/Q2 journals | Three ISI articles were published in Q1/Q2 journals (reaching a total of 6 articles published out of 8 proposed for the entire project) |
7 | Participation in at least five scientific events | Five participations in international scientific events were recorded (reaching a total of 7 participations out of 10 proposed for the entire project) |
8 | Participation in at least 3 invention exhibitions | Thirteen participations in invention exhibitions were registered, obtaining a series of awards, presented on the project website (indicator exceeded considering the level proposed for the entire project) |
9 | Updating the project web page and continuing the online campaign on social media | The project website, both in Romanian and in English, has been continuously updated; the project was disseminated through social media |
10 | Other activities | Other activities were also carried out: – Workshop organization (indicator accomplished 100% at project level) – Presenting an invited talk in a foreign laboratory on the project’s topic – Submission of two patent applications (100% completed indicator at the project level) – Publication of a book chapter (indicator achieved 100% at the project level) |
Summary
Acidic attack by cariogenic bacteria associated with plaque biofilm development is responsible for dental caries, a biofilm-dependent infectious disease that damages teeth through mineral loss and has a high incidence of the use of polymers for clinical restoration. The complexity of oral biofilms contributes to the difficulty of developing new effective dental materials. The oral cavity is an ideal environment for microbial cell growth, persistence and plaque formation. The presence of different microniches leads to the appearance of different biofilm communities, formed on the surface of the teeth, above the gingival crevice or at the subgingival level, on the tongue, mucous membranes or on dental prosthetic materials. In this context, nanotechnology has the potential to be explored in the development of bioactive dental materials to reduce or modulate the activities of caries-related bacteria. The main goal of the project is to propose a potential dental restoration material with antibacterial properties simultaneously with increased mechanical resistance, based on substituted apatitic nanomaterials (decorated with metal nanoparticles) and natural compounds, applicable in glass ionomer cements. The degree of novelty of the proposed project emerges from the properties of the proposed material related to the potential final application: improved mechanical resistance and simultaneous antibacterial activity of the structures developed based on nanomaterials, applicable in glass ionomer cements.
The activities planned to be carried out during the third stage of the project were:
a. Act 3.1 – Evaluation of the antimicrobial effects and biocompatibility of NAM enriched with natural compounds
b. Act 3.2 – Evaluation of the mechanical characteristics of apatite materials enriched with natural compounds
c. Act 3.3 – Obtaining and characterizing glass ionomer cements based on nanomaterials enriched with natural compounds (NGI) with improved mechanical properties.
d. Act 3.4 – Evaluation of the antimicrobial properties and biocompatibility of NGI
e. Act 3.5 – Evaluation of the release of active compounds under conditions similar to real ones (synthetic saliva solutions).
f. Act 3.6 – Evaluation of antibacterial effects and biocompatibility under conditions similar to real ones (synthetic saliva solutions)
g. Act 3.7 – Evaluation of mechanical properties, adhesion and thermal insulation properties under conditions similar to real ones (synthetic saliva solutions); validation of the proposed solution
h. Act 3.8 – Development of technical documentation for technology and products and patent applications.
i. Act 3.9 – Dissemination of results and the project
The proposed activities were fully implemented, thus supporting the successful completion of the project. Thus, activities related to the synthesis and optimization of the phytosynthesis of nanoparticles were continued, the antimicrobial effects, biocompatibility and mechanical properties of apatitic nanomaterials enriched with natural compounds were evaluated, glass ionomer cements based on nanomaterials enriched with natural compounds with improved mechanical properties were obtained and characterized, their antimicrobial properties and biocompatibility were evaluated, as well as the evaluation of the release of active compounds, antibacterial effects and biocompatibility under conditions similar to real ones (in synthetic saliva solutions), and their mechanical properties, adhesion and thermal insulation properties. The proposed materials were validated by external laboratories. In addition, the technical documentation for the technology and products was developed and the work on the development of patent applications was completed.
During this stage, the dissemination activity of the project and of the obtained results was completed, with significant exceedances of most of the assumed indicators being recorded.
The results obtained were disseminated within the scientific community, the results of the dissemination being presented extensively on the project website (Romanian version – https://icechim.ro/project/nanodent/, English version – https://icechim.ro/project/nanodent_en/).
The accomplishment degree of estimated results
Estimated result | Obtained results | Accomplishment degree |
---|---|---|
Final report on the development of modified apatite nanomaterials enriched with natural compounds; | The final report on the development of modified apatite nanomaterials was completed (chapters 1 and 2 of the phase scientific and technical report) | 100% |
Report on the development of platforms based on glass ionomer cements/nanomaterials enriched with natural compounds (NGI); | The report on the development of platforms based on glass ionomer cements/nanomaterials enriched with natural compounds (NGI) was completed (chapter 3 of the phase scientific and technical report) | 100% |
Report on NGI properties; | The report on NGI properties was completed (chapters 4-7 of the RST). External validation of the materials was completed by an independent laboratory (from a Medicine University) (chapter 7 of the phase scientific and technical report). | 100% |
Technical documentation for technology and products; | Technical documentation for technology and products was prepared (chapter 8 of the phase scientific and technical report) | 100% |
At least two patent applications (for the entire project period); | During phase III, one patent application was submitted. In total, three patent applications were submitted (chapter 9 of the phase scientific and technical report) | 150% |
1 workshop for presentation and promotion of the project and possible applications (for the entire project period) | During phase III, one workshop was organized. In total, two workshops were organized | 200% |
Publication of a book/book chapter by an international publishing house (for the entire project period) | One book chapter was published (reported in stage II) | 100% |
Submission for publication of at least eight ISI articles in Q1/Q2 journals (of which 3 in phase III) | Ten articles were submitted for publication in Q1 and Q2 journals, of which 9 were published (four in Q1 and 5 in Q2). In the third phase, four articles were submitted for publication/published. | 125% |
Participation in at least ten scientific events (of which at least four in phase III) | Participation in 14 scientific events was recorded (of which six as invited lectures); of these, seven were recorded in phase III | 140% |
Participation in at least six invention salons (of which at least 2 in phase III) | Participation in 25 invention salons was recorded (of which nine in stage III) | 417% |
The estimated impact of this project is considerable, with the potential to redefine current dental practices and bring major innovations in the field of dental restorative materials. The three patent applications filed reflect essential advances in the development of advanced composite materials, which combine nanotechnology with phytonanotechnology, offering multidimensional solutions to current clinical challenges.
The most significant result of the project is the development of dental restorative materials that incorporate both advanced nanotechnology and phytonanotechnology – an innovative branch that capitalizes on phytosynthesized metal nanoparticles (using natural extracts). These materials have been validated by independent laboratories, demonstrating an optimal combination of biocompatibility, improved antimicrobial activity and increased mechanical strength. These characteristics position the materials as revolutionary, with the potential to significantly reduce the risk of post-treatment infections, extend the lifespan of dental restorations and reduce the need for re-interventions.
This achievement not only opens up new perspectives for future research, but also has a direct impact on the quality of life of patients, offering them safer and more effective treatments. In addition, the use of phytonanotechnology contributes to sustainability by integrating natural resources into manufacturing processes, aligning with global trends to reduce the ecological impact of medical materials. Thus, our project demonstrates how fundamental and applied research can generate sustainable solutions, with profound implications in both the field of science and practical applications.
In addition, the project exceeded the assumed indicators regarding the contribution to the achievement of the program objectives, by:
a. Submission for publication of ten articles in Q1 (five) and Q2 (five) journals, in open-access mode, without costs associated with publication. Nine of these articles had been published at the time of writing the report, totaling 48 citations (SCOPUS), respectively 41 citations (WoS); assumed indicator: eight articles submitted for publication
b. Participation in fourteen scientific events, of which six were invited lectures (proof of the high visibility of the project director); assumed indicator: at least 10 participations in international conferences.
c. Participation in twenty-five events dedicated to invention and innovation (participations resulting in the awarding of an impressive number of awards, presented on the project website, including grand prizes of the exhibition or individual recognitions); assumed indicator: at least 6 participations in invention exhibitions.
d. Submission of three patent applications, proof of the high applicability of the results obtained; assumed indicator: at least two patent applications submitted.
e. Organization of two workshops to present the project and the results obtained; assumed indicator: organization of a workshop.
f. Publication of a book chapter at an international publishing house (Springer); assumed indicator: publication of a book/book chapter at an international publishing house;
g. Increasing the visibility of the researchers involved in the project. At the time of submitting the project, the research team had the following scientometric indicators (cumulative values): published papers – 522, citations – 4534, cumulative Hirsch index – 103. At the time of submitting this report, the scientometric indicators are as follows (cumulative values): published papers – 839, citations – 11727, cumulative Hirsch index – 163. Also, six papers presented as invited lectures (previously presented) and one visit as an invited professor were recorded.
h. Supporting young researchers: with the support of the project, three doctoral researchers publicly defended their doctoral theses (in September 2024).